November, 03 2014, 03:00pm EDT
For Immediate Release
Contact:
Phone: 301.270.6477,Email:,nirsnet@nirs.org
35 Clean Energy Organizations Urge DOE to End Nuclear Loan Program
35 clean energy organizations submitted formal comments today telling the Department of Energy (DOE) to end its taxpayer-funded loan program for nuclear reactors and either return the $10.2 Billion in available funds to the U.S. Treasury or move them to the DOE's renewable energy loan program.
The comments came in response to a draft "Solicitation Announcement" for "Advanced Nuclear Energy Projects " released by DOE last month. Today was the final day of a 30-day public comment period on the announcement.
WASHINGTON
35 clean energy organizations submitted formal comments today telling the Department of Energy (DOE) to end its taxpayer-funded loan program for nuclear reactors and either return the $10.2 Billion in available funds to the U.S. Treasury or move them to the DOE's renewable energy loan program.
The comments came in response to a draft "Solicitation Announcement" for "Advanced Nuclear Energy Projects " released by DOE last month. Today was the final day of a 30-day public comment period on the announcement.
The DOE's loan program was first authorized under the 2005 Energy Policy Act, and in 2007 Congress authorized the Department to offer $18.5 Billion in loans from the Federal Financing Bank or loan guarantees for commercial lenders to encourage the construction of new, "advanced" nuclear reactors. Only one project, Southern Company's Vogtle reactors in Georgia, have received any money under the program. One other project, the proposed Calvert Cliffs-3 reactor in Maryland, reportedly was offered a loan under the program but one of the lead entities in that project, Constellation Energy (now part of Exelon Corporation) instead decided to abandon the reactor entirely.
DOE has been unable to find any takers for the remainder of its $10.2 Billion in authorized funds.
Given that reality, DOE is attempting with this solicitation to expand what it can lend the money for. DOE now proposes to offer funds for "small modular reactors" (SMRs) despite the fact that no design for such reactors has been submitted to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission for certification, nor have any utilities submitted an application to build an SMR.
DOE is also attempting to use the funds to help nuclear utilities pay for power uprates and safety upgrades to existing reactors despite the explicit Congressional intent of the program to encourage new reactor construction.
The 35 organizational commenters said that "These categories are nothing more than an attempt to prop up--at taxpayer risk--current reactors that have become uneconomical due to age-related deterioration, poor reactor design, or simply lower-cost competition from electricity generation sources like solar and wind power."
They went on to warn, "Should the DOE proceed with this idea, it will be litigated (yet another waste of taxpayer money), and it is highly unlikely DOE will prevail given the plain language of the Act."
Although the organizations described the DOE's nuclear loan program as "an abject failure," they did not blame DOE for that failure:
"The nuclear loan program was established at a time when too many politicians believed nuclear industry hype that a nuclear power "renaissance" was just around the corner, and some government support would be extremely helpful in its launch. But the "renaissance" didn't materialize and nuclear power is back to where it was 15 years or so ago, except in worse position. Then, it was simply a moribund industry. Now, it is not only moribund but obsolete--new technologies, from rooftop solar with battery storage to smart grids to the unexpected effectiveness of energy efficiency programs and mandates, to the growing concept of distributed generation, which provides not only safer and cheaper power, but also a more secure grid; have risen to take nuclear's place....
"Rather than attempt to resuscitate its failed nuclear loan program, the DOE should acknowledge the program's failure and explain to policymakers that it failed not because of DOE's policies, but because of much larger market forces, the effect of multiple nuclear meltdowns, and the rise of new technologies.
"DOE should not only withdraw its solicitation but should either simply end this program or seek to have its funds transferred to its renewable energy loan program, which has shown some evidence of genuine accomplishment."
The full comments are available at: https://www.nirs.org/neconomics/doelgcomments.pdf
Nuclear Information and Resource Service is the information and networking center for people and organizations concerned about nuclear power, radioactive waste, radiation, and sustainable energy issues.
LATEST NEWS
Study Reveals Up to 11 Million Tons of Plastic Polluting Ocean Floors
"Every minute, a garbage truck's worth of plastic enters the ocean," researchers said.
Apr 07, 2024
The amount of plastic waste littering the Earth's ocean floors could be up to 100 times the quantity floating on the surface, according to a study published this week.
Researchers at the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization (CSIRO)—an Australian government agency—and the University of Toronto in Canada found that up to 11 million tons of plastic are polluting the planet's ocean floors, including microplastics and larger objects like fishing nets, cups, and bags.
"We know that millions of tons of plastic waste enter our oceans every year but what we didn't know is how much of this pollution ends up on our ocean floor," CSIRO senior research scientist and study co-author Denise Hardesty said in a statement. "We discovered that the ocean floor has become a resting place, or reservoir, for most plastic pollution, with between 3 to 11 million tons of plastic estimated to be sinking to the ocean floor."
Study leader Alice Zhu, a doctoral candidate at the University of Toronto, said that "the ocean surface is a temporary resting place of plastic so it is expected that if we can stop plastic entering our oceans, the amount would be reduced."
"However, our research found that plastic will continue to end up in the deep ocean," Zhu stated. "These findings help to fill a longstanding knowledge gap on the behavior of plastic in the marine environment."
“Understanding the driving forces behind the transport and accumulation of plastic in the deep ocean will help to inform source reduction and environmental remediation efforts, thereby reducing the risks that plastic pollution may pose to marine life," she added.
The study is part of CSIRO's Ending Plastic Waste program, whose goal is "an 80% reduction in plastic waste entering the Australian environment by 2030."
Humans produce approximately 440 million tons of plastics annually, or roughly the combined weight of every person on the planet. Plastic pollution harms not only the environment and ecosystems, but also human health and economies.
Plastic use is expected to double by 2040. Negotiations on a global plastics treaty have made little progress amid lobbying by the fossil fuel and petrochemical industries.
Keep ReadingShow Less
Orbán Challenger Promises New Era of Hungarian Politics at Massive Budapest Rally
"We were pitted against each other instead of allowing us to band together," said political newcomer Péter Magyar. "We will put an end to this now."
Apr 07, 2024
At least tens of thousands of Hungarians took to the streets of Budapest on Saturday to rally against right-wing Prime Minister Viktor Orbán and in support of a political newcomer who recently launched a movement that plans to field candidates in European and local elections in June.
Demonstrations against Orbán's increasingly autocratic 14-year rule were sparked by Péter Magyar, a lawyer and former associate of the prime minister who recently released an audio recording exposing corruption in the ruling Fidesz party. Protesters gathered Saturday in Kossuth Square outside Parliament, waving Hungarian flags and chanting "Orbán resign!", "We are not afraid!", and other slogans.
"Step by step, brick by brick, we are taking back our homeland and building a new country, a sovereign, modern, European Hungary," Magyar, 43, told supporters.
"Our elected leaders have incited the Hungarian people against each other for the past 20 years," he added. "Whether the fate of our country went well or we were close to bankruptcy, we were pitted against each other instead of allowing us to band together. We will put an end to this now."
One protester toldAgence France-Presse that "something needed to be done because it's insane how much this government has gotten away with."
Magyar, the ex-husband of former Justice Minister Judit Varga, last month released an audio recording of his ex-wife discussing an attempt by members of Orbán's inner circle to interfere in a corruption case. Varga and Hungarian President Katalin Novak resigned in February over an unrelated child sex abuse pardoning scandal.
Zsuzsanna Szigeti, a 46-year-old healthcare worker attending Saturday's rally, toldReuters that "we had known that there is corruption, but [Magyar] says it as an insider and confirmed it for us."
Domestic and international critics have accused Orbán of systematically eroding Hungary's democratic institutions, tightening his grip over the country's political system, and consolidating control over much of the media to strengthen Fidesz and its parliamentary supermajority. European Union leaders have condemned Orbán's rule, calling his government a "hybrid regime of electoral autocracy." Orbán describes it as "illiberal democracy," while touting its universal appeal to international conservatives, including former U.S. President Donald Trump, the presumptive 2024 GOP presidential nominee.
European leaders also bristle at Orban's warm personal relationship with Russian President Vladimir Putin, although the Hungarian leader did condemn Russia's invasion of Ukraine and voted along with the rest of the 27-nation E.U. to impose economic sanctions on Moscow.
Human rights have deteriorated markedly during Orbán's tenure, especially for LGBTQ+ people, migrants, women, and Roma. The E.U. has withheld billions of dollars in funding in response.
Keep ReadingShow Less
Atmospheric Greenhouse Gas Concentrations Hit New Record Levels
"As these numbers show, we still have a lot of work to do to make meaningful progress in reducing the amount of greenhouse gases accumulating in the atmosphere," said one NOAA scientist.
Apr 06, 2024
The three most critical heat-trapping gases in Earth's atmosphere again reached record levels last year, the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration said Friday, underscoring the inadequacy of efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions amid the worsening climate emergency.
NOAA said the three most important human-caused greenhouse gases—carbon dioxide (CO2), methane, and nitrous oxide—"continued their steady climb during 2023."
While the levels of these heat-trapping gases did not rise "quite as high as the record jumps observed in recent years," the figures "were in line with the steep increases observed during the past decade."
"We're caught between a rock and a charred place."
Global surface CO2 concentrations averaged 419.3 parts per million (ppm) last year, an increase of 2.8 ppm. It was the 12th straight year in which worldwide CO2 concentrations rose by more than 2 ppm.
Atmospheric methane—which while not as abundant as CO2 is up to 87 times more potent over a 20-year period—increased by 10 parts per billion (ppb) to 1,922.6 ppb, while nitrous oxide rose by 1 ppb to 336.7 ppb.
"As these numbers show, we still have a lot of work to do to make meaningful progress in reducing the amount of greenhouse gases accumulating in the atmosphere," Vanda Grubišić, director of NOAA's Global Monitoring Laboratory, said in a statement.
According to NOAA:
The amount of CO2 in the atmosphere today is comparable to where it was around 4.3 million years ago during the mid-Pliocene epoch, when sea level was about 75 feet higher than today, the average temperature was 7°F higher than in pre-industrial times, and large forests occupied areas of the Arctic that are now tundra.
About half of the CO2 emissions from fossil fuels to date have been absorbed at the Earth's surface, divided roughly equally between oceans and land ecosystems, including grasslands and forests. The CO2 absorbed by the world's oceans contributes to ocean acidification, which is causing a fundamental change in the chemistry of the ocean, with impacts to marine life and the people who depend on [it]. The oceans have also absorbed an estimated 90% of the excess heat trapped in the atmosphere by greenhouse gases.
"Methane's decadal spike should terrify us," Rob Jackson, a Stanford University climate scientist who heads the Global Carbon Project—which tracks global emissions but wasn't part of the NOAA effort—toldNBC News.
"Fossil fuel pollution is warming natural systems like wetlands and permafrost," Jackson added. "Those ecosystems are releasing even more greenhouse gases as they heat up. We're caught between a rock and a charred place."
Keep ReadingShow Less
Most Popular