Rep. Jamaal Bowman (D-N.Y.) said on December 15, 2021 that "now, we are faced with a false choice between saving our democracy from the existential threat of fascism and meeting the immediate needs of people." (Photo: Stefani Reynolds/Getty Images)
Dec 15, 2021
Congressman Jamaal Bowman on Wednesday called out his U.S. Senate colleagues following reports that Democrats may put off a vote on the Build Back Better Act until the new year and instead turn their attention to advancing voting rights legislation.
"We can pass both bills and must do so immediately."
Highlighting that 26 days have passed since the Democrat-controlled U.S. House of Representatives "did its job" to deliver on President Joe Biden's full agenda by approving the budget reconciliation package, the New York Democrat said that "now, we are faced with a false choice between saving our democracy from the existential threat of fascism and meeting the immediate needs of people."
"If we fail to deliver on Build Back Better, this is the last child tax credit payment that my constituents will see, despite tremendous food insecurity and child poverty in our district," Bowman notedwai. "The people in my district are all too familiar with the status quo and are counting on my colleagues in the Senate to address their needs by passing the Build Back Better Act."
\u201cThere is not a good enough reason for the Senate to withhold passing the Build Back Better.\u201d— Congressman Jamaal Bowman (@Congressman Jamaal Bowman) 1639601822
Bowman--one of the few House progressives who voted against a bipartisan infrastructure bill after right-wing Democrats decoupled it from the Build Back Better Act--said former President Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal "was transformative, but only for some Americans." He warned that "we cannot repeat the same mistake in this generation-especially when seniors, women, and people of color bore the brunt of this pandemic."
"We have the opportunity to deliver transformative policy for the most impacted, disrupt the status quo, and put people and families first," he continued. "There is not a good enough reason for the Senate to withhold passing the Build Back Better Act in order to pass voting rights. Saving our democracy is urgent and existential; it doesn't mean we have to pause on meeting the immediate needs of people. We can pass both bills and must do so immediately."
Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.), chair of the nearly 100-member Congressional Progressive Caucus, shared Bowman's position that the Senate must urgently act on not only the Build Back Better Act but also voting rights legislation--which has been repeatedly blocked by Senate Republicans, bolstering calls to reform or abolish the filibuster.
"Too much is at stake for the Senate to settle for this false choice--they must do BOTH," Jayapal tweeted Wednesday. "End the filibuster and get this done."
\u201cThe idea that the Senate has to choose between passing Build Back Better and voting rights is a false choice. The people elected us to deliver \u2014 not pit their priorities against each other.\n\nThe Senate can, and must, do both. Without delay.\n\nOur communities need relief NOW.\u201d— Progressive Caucus (@Progressive Caucus) 1639607193
Bowman and Jayapal's comments came after multiple media outlets reported that talks about the $1.75 trillion social infrastructure and climate package between Biden and Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) had "soured," partly due to the expanded child tax credit (CTC).
Thanks to the expanded CTC, eligible families receive monthly payments of up to $300 per child under the age of six and $250 per child between the ages of six and 17. If Senate Democrats wait to approve a continuation of the program, checks for January could be delayed. Stalling or ending the initiative could force millions of children back into or into deeper poverty.
Manchin--whose attempts to water down the package have long delayed its passage--pushed back against the reports Wednesday, telling journalists that claims he wants to strip the CTC from the bill were "a lot of bad rumors" and he has "always been for child tax credits."
The West Virginia Democrat also snapped at HuffPost reporter Authur Delaney when questioned about the CTC, saying: "This is bullshit. You're bullshit."
\u201cI had asked if it was true he wanted CTC out of BBB. \n\n\u201cI've always been for child tax credits,\u201d he said.\n\nSo I asked if he wants it to continue paying parents $300 a month, and he said he was not going to "negotiate" with me and that I'm bullshit\u201d— Arthur Delaney \ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\uddf8 (@Arthur Delaney \ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\uddf8) 1639590793
CNN's Manu Raju spoke with Manchin about the CTC Wednesday night and explained in a series of tweets that the senator "said that he's objecting to a one-year extension of child tax credit because he believes it hides [the] true cost, since [it] will likely be extended."
Manchin told Raju that the CTC should be extended 10 years--but, as the journalist noted, "extending it for the next decade would blow up the price tag and would require wholesale changes of a bill," given that the senator won't agree to a higher topline number.
According to Raju, Manchin also "said that if it increases the price tag and they want to keep the CTC, Democrats should drop other programs in order to make it all fit under $1.75 trillion."
\u201cLet's be clear about what's happening with BBB - Joe Manchin is fighting to make families with children poorer for no reason. \n\nIf he's concerned about the cost of the CTC he could easily demand tax hikes on the rich to pay for it, but he won't. The rich are more important to him\u201d— Patriotic Millionaires (@Patriotic Millionaires) 1639597014
In a Wednesday statement about the CTC fight, People's Action director of federal affairs Megan Essaheb urged Manchin to change his position.
"Today is the last day families will get child tax credit checks unless Congress passes the Build Back Better Act to extend the life-changing program," Essaheb pointed out. "This legislation will only reduce costs for families and help them thrive--it's a no-brainer that Manchin needs to get behind."
"The child tax credit cut child poverty in the U.S. in half," she continued. "We have to renew it and continue supporting the millions of hurting families in West Virginia, and across the country. Sen. Manchin should listen to his constituents, not corporate interests, and deliver on the promises Democrats made when they were elected the majority."
Also rejecting any suggestion that senators must trade action on one priority for another, Essaheb said that "the Senate should pass both the Build Back Better Act and critical voting rights legislation as fast as possible."
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
childrenpoliticsjamaal bowmancongressional progressive caucuspramila jayapaljoe manchinvoting rightspeople's actionus senate
Congressman Jamaal Bowman on Wednesday called out his U.S. Senate colleagues following reports that Democrats may put off a vote on the Build Back Better Act until the new year and instead turn their attention to advancing voting rights legislation.
"We can pass both bills and must do so immediately."
Highlighting that 26 days have passed since the Democrat-controlled U.S. House of Representatives "did its job" to deliver on President Joe Biden's full agenda by approving the budget reconciliation package, the New York Democrat said that "now, we are faced with a false choice between saving our democracy from the existential threat of fascism and meeting the immediate needs of people."
"If we fail to deliver on Build Back Better, this is the last child tax credit payment that my constituents will see, despite tremendous food insecurity and child poverty in our district," Bowman notedwai. "The people in my district are all too familiar with the status quo and are counting on my colleagues in the Senate to address their needs by passing the Build Back Better Act."
\u201cThere is not a good enough reason for the Senate to withhold passing the Build Back Better.\u201d— Congressman Jamaal Bowman (@Congressman Jamaal Bowman) 1639601822
Bowman--one of the few House progressives who voted against a bipartisan infrastructure bill after right-wing Democrats decoupled it from the Build Back Better Act--said former President Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal "was transformative, but only for some Americans." He warned that "we cannot repeat the same mistake in this generation-especially when seniors, women, and people of color bore the brunt of this pandemic."
"We have the opportunity to deliver transformative policy for the most impacted, disrupt the status quo, and put people and families first," he continued. "There is not a good enough reason for the Senate to withhold passing the Build Back Better Act in order to pass voting rights. Saving our democracy is urgent and existential; it doesn't mean we have to pause on meeting the immediate needs of people. We can pass both bills and must do so immediately."
Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.), chair of the nearly 100-member Congressional Progressive Caucus, shared Bowman's position that the Senate must urgently act on not only the Build Back Better Act but also voting rights legislation--which has been repeatedly blocked by Senate Republicans, bolstering calls to reform or abolish the filibuster.
"Too much is at stake for the Senate to settle for this false choice--they must do BOTH," Jayapal tweeted Wednesday. "End the filibuster and get this done."
\u201cThe idea that the Senate has to choose between passing Build Back Better and voting rights is a false choice. The people elected us to deliver \u2014 not pit their priorities against each other.\n\nThe Senate can, and must, do both. Without delay.\n\nOur communities need relief NOW.\u201d— Progressive Caucus (@Progressive Caucus) 1639607193
Bowman and Jayapal's comments came after multiple media outlets reported that talks about the $1.75 trillion social infrastructure and climate package between Biden and Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) had "soured," partly due to the expanded child tax credit (CTC).
Thanks to the expanded CTC, eligible families receive monthly payments of up to $300 per child under the age of six and $250 per child between the ages of six and 17. If Senate Democrats wait to approve a continuation of the program, checks for January could be delayed. Stalling or ending the initiative could force millions of children back into or into deeper poverty.
Manchin--whose attempts to water down the package have long delayed its passage--pushed back against the reports Wednesday, telling journalists that claims he wants to strip the CTC from the bill were "a lot of bad rumors" and he has "always been for child tax credits."
The West Virginia Democrat also snapped at HuffPost reporter Authur Delaney when questioned about the CTC, saying: "This is bullshit. You're bullshit."
\u201cI had asked if it was true he wanted CTC out of BBB. \n\n\u201cI've always been for child tax credits,\u201d he said.\n\nSo I asked if he wants it to continue paying parents $300 a month, and he said he was not going to "negotiate" with me and that I'm bullshit\u201d— Arthur Delaney \ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\uddf8 (@Arthur Delaney \ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\uddf8) 1639590793
CNN's Manu Raju spoke with Manchin about the CTC Wednesday night and explained in a series of tweets that the senator "said that he's objecting to a one-year extension of child tax credit because he believes it hides [the] true cost, since [it] will likely be extended."
Manchin told Raju that the CTC should be extended 10 years--but, as the journalist noted, "extending it for the next decade would blow up the price tag and would require wholesale changes of a bill," given that the senator won't agree to a higher topline number.
According to Raju, Manchin also "said that if it increases the price tag and they want to keep the CTC, Democrats should drop other programs in order to make it all fit under $1.75 trillion."
\u201cLet's be clear about what's happening with BBB - Joe Manchin is fighting to make families with children poorer for no reason. \n\nIf he's concerned about the cost of the CTC he could easily demand tax hikes on the rich to pay for it, but he won't. The rich are more important to him\u201d— Patriotic Millionaires (@Patriotic Millionaires) 1639597014
In a Wednesday statement about the CTC fight, People's Action director of federal affairs Megan Essaheb urged Manchin to change his position.
"Today is the last day families will get child tax credit checks unless Congress passes the Build Back Better Act to extend the life-changing program," Essaheb pointed out. "This legislation will only reduce costs for families and help them thrive--it's a no-brainer that Manchin needs to get behind."
"The child tax credit cut child poverty in the U.S. in half," she continued. "We have to renew it and continue supporting the millions of hurting families in West Virginia, and across the country. Sen. Manchin should listen to his constituents, not corporate interests, and deliver on the promises Democrats made when they were elected the majority."
Also rejecting any suggestion that senators must trade action on one priority for another, Essaheb said that "the Senate should pass both the Build Back Better Act and critical voting rights legislation as fast as possible."
Congressman Jamaal Bowman on Wednesday called out his U.S. Senate colleagues following reports that Democrats may put off a vote on the Build Back Better Act until the new year and instead turn their attention to advancing voting rights legislation.
"We can pass both bills and must do so immediately."
Highlighting that 26 days have passed since the Democrat-controlled U.S. House of Representatives "did its job" to deliver on President Joe Biden's full agenda by approving the budget reconciliation package, the New York Democrat said that "now, we are faced with a false choice between saving our democracy from the existential threat of fascism and meeting the immediate needs of people."
"If we fail to deliver on Build Back Better, this is the last child tax credit payment that my constituents will see, despite tremendous food insecurity and child poverty in our district," Bowman notedwai. "The people in my district are all too familiar with the status quo and are counting on my colleagues in the Senate to address their needs by passing the Build Back Better Act."
\u201cThere is not a good enough reason for the Senate to withhold passing the Build Back Better.\u201d— Congressman Jamaal Bowman (@Congressman Jamaal Bowman) 1639601822
Bowman--one of the few House progressives who voted against a bipartisan infrastructure bill after right-wing Democrats decoupled it from the Build Back Better Act--said former President Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal "was transformative, but only for some Americans." He warned that "we cannot repeat the same mistake in this generation-especially when seniors, women, and people of color bore the brunt of this pandemic."
"We have the opportunity to deliver transformative policy for the most impacted, disrupt the status quo, and put people and families first," he continued. "There is not a good enough reason for the Senate to withhold passing the Build Back Better Act in order to pass voting rights. Saving our democracy is urgent and existential; it doesn't mean we have to pause on meeting the immediate needs of people. We can pass both bills and must do so immediately."
Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.), chair of the nearly 100-member Congressional Progressive Caucus, shared Bowman's position that the Senate must urgently act on not only the Build Back Better Act but also voting rights legislation--which has been repeatedly blocked by Senate Republicans, bolstering calls to reform or abolish the filibuster.
"Too much is at stake for the Senate to settle for this false choice--they must do BOTH," Jayapal tweeted Wednesday. "End the filibuster and get this done."
\u201cThe idea that the Senate has to choose between passing Build Back Better and voting rights is a false choice. The people elected us to deliver \u2014 not pit their priorities against each other.\n\nThe Senate can, and must, do both. Without delay.\n\nOur communities need relief NOW.\u201d— Progressive Caucus (@Progressive Caucus) 1639607193
Bowman and Jayapal's comments came after multiple media outlets reported that talks about the $1.75 trillion social infrastructure and climate package between Biden and Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) had "soured," partly due to the expanded child tax credit (CTC).
Thanks to the expanded CTC, eligible families receive monthly payments of up to $300 per child under the age of six and $250 per child between the ages of six and 17. If Senate Democrats wait to approve a continuation of the program, checks for January could be delayed. Stalling or ending the initiative could force millions of children back into or into deeper poverty.
Manchin--whose attempts to water down the package have long delayed its passage--pushed back against the reports Wednesday, telling journalists that claims he wants to strip the CTC from the bill were "a lot of bad rumors" and he has "always been for child tax credits."
The West Virginia Democrat also snapped at HuffPost reporter Authur Delaney when questioned about the CTC, saying: "This is bullshit. You're bullshit."
\u201cI had asked if it was true he wanted CTC out of BBB. \n\n\u201cI've always been for child tax credits,\u201d he said.\n\nSo I asked if he wants it to continue paying parents $300 a month, and he said he was not going to "negotiate" with me and that I'm bullshit\u201d— Arthur Delaney \ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\uddf8 (@Arthur Delaney \ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\uddf8) 1639590793
CNN's Manu Raju spoke with Manchin about the CTC Wednesday night and explained in a series of tweets that the senator "said that he's objecting to a one-year extension of child tax credit because he believes it hides [the] true cost, since [it] will likely be extended."
Manchin told Raju that the CTC should be extended 10 years--but, as the journalist noted, "extending it for the next decade would blow up the price tag and would require wholesale changes of a bill," given that the senator won't agree to a higher topline number.
According to Raju, Manchin also "said that if it increases the price tag and they want to keep the CTC, Democrats should drop other programs in order to make it all fit under $1.75 trillion."
\u201cLet's be clear about what's happening with BBB - Joe Manchin is fighting to make families with children poorer for no reason. \n\nIf he's concerned about the cost of the CTC he could easily demand tax hikes on the rich to pay for it, but he won't. The rich are more important to him\u201d— Patriotic Millionaires (@Patriotic Millionaires) 1639597014
In a Wednesday statement about the CTC fight, People's Action director of federal affairs Megan Essaheb urged Manchin to change his position.
"Today is the last day families will get child tax credit checks unless Congress passes the Build Back Better Act to extend the life-changing program," Essaheb pointed out. "This legislation will only reduce costs for families and help them thrive--it's a no-brainer that Manchin needs to get behind."
"The child tax credit cut child poverty in the U.S. in half," she continued. "We have to renew it and continue supporting the millions of hurting families in West Virginia, and across the country. Sen. Manchin should listen to his constituents, not corporate interests, and deliver on the promises Democrats made when they were elected the majority."
Also rejecting any suggestion that senators must trade action on one priority for another, Essaheb said that "the Senate should pass both the Build Back Better Act and critical voting rights legislation as fast as possible."
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.