COVID-19 Sweeping Through Ranks of US Immigrant Farmworkers and Meatpackers

The largely immigrant work force is composed partly of H2A seasonal visa holders, tending and harvesting the agricultural fields through the warmer months, and a larger proportion of year round undocumented workers, also working the fields as well as staffing poultry and pork processing factories. The elevated bacterial load experienced by these people already working in close quarters under unsanitary conditions, as well as additional exposure to often carcinogenic pesticides and other chemicals, make farmworkers and meat processors particularly vulnerable to illness.

Migrant and seasonal farmworkers live crowded together in makeshift housing, sometimes just simple particle board structures with communal toilets. They bus to the fields to perform the backbreaking and dangerous labor employers struggle to find native-born workers to do. Sanitary facilities are almost non-existent. Bathrooms (porta-johns) are only required to be provided if the field is larger than 1/4 mile; Norma recounted that while she was told the first field she worked at was too small to have a portable toilet, the second field's toilet, which was servicing forty workers, was out of commission as it had not been cleaned in six weeks.

Meat processors work on the chain, a fast-paced assembly line wherein workers toil side by side repetitively slicing, yanking and hauling pork, chicken, beef and turkey carcasses. "We work shoulder to shoulder. We're very close to each other," explained Maria, a 15 year veteran with Butterball, the turkey breeder and processor. "I've had a fever and flu symptoms, but I take Tylenol and keep working." While a tenured employee like Maria has health insurance, she does not get any other benefits. "If we get sick, or are not allowed to work due to the pandemic, we don't get paid."

According to EFM Executive Director Lariza Garzon, "This crisis is highlighting the inequities that workers live through every day. Workers are struggling with a lack of protection at work, concerns about their health, not qualifying for government aid, low wages, poor housing, lack of childcare, fear regarding their immigration status, etc."

The history of immigrant labor and abusive workplaces runs deep in U.S. food production. In 1906, Upton Sinclair published "The Jungle", a book that shocked Americans about the dangerous and unsavory conditions experienced by immigrant workers in the nation's meat packing plants. Almost a century later, in December 2001, the US government charged Tyson Foods with smuggling immigrants across the Mexican border to work in its plants and providing them with false documentation. In less than two years, the company was acquitted of the charges, asserting that it was not responsible for the hiring practices of outside agencies, though three Tyson managers opted for plea deals, one of whom committed suicide.

A 2011 report by the Economic Policy Institute (EPI) found that a 40% increase in farmworker pay, bringing annual salaries from $10,000 to $14,000 a year, would only increase consumer spending a mere $16 a year. The author, Philip Martin, Professor of Agricultural and Resource Economics at the University of California-Davis, concluded, "In short, increasing farmworker wages to raise farmworkers out of poverty poses little threat to consumer pocketbooks or U.S. exports."

Aside from the lack of protective equipment, distancing and other safeguards for agricultural and meat processing workers, shutdowns due to Covid-19 reveal the lack of basic benefits such as sick days and unemployment insurance. "I work in the fields with tobacco and sweet potatoes, but I've been out of work since February because of the coronavirus," said Flor at the teleconference.

"Since the epidemic, we don't have any work, or very little," added Jose, a migrant worker who had travelled up from Florida with his wife and children to work the sweet potato and blueberry fields and has been cutting grass to make ends meet. "We haven't received any assistance. With the children at home, we have even more expenses. We earn very little as it is, and the little we have is not enough."

EFWM Reverend Ann Elliott Hodges-Copple says that due to the pandemic, they cannot make the food deliveries or check on camp conditions as they used to. And their food drives are now swamped. Whereas they used to be attended by 70 to 90 families, the last two have hosted 300 and 220. With no income, no paid leave, no unemployment benefits, no stimulus checks, no health care, no child care, and the possibility of falling ill, the need in the region is enormous.

Tyson Foods Inc., the country's biggest meat processor, is still not offering paid sick days, but says it is "eliminating any punitive effect for missing work due to illness."